When to Reply on Twitter: The Golden Window
Timing matters more than you think. Here's the science behind when to reply for maximum visibility and why the first hour is everything.
Why Timing Matters
Most people reply whenever they see a post. But data shows that the same high-quality reply gets 3x more engagement if posted in the first hour vs. the 12th hour. Timing isn't just nice to have—it's essential.
📊 The Data
Of engagement happens in the first 2 hours
Remaining engagement over next 22 hours
The Golden Hour
The first 60 minutes after a post goes live is the golden window. Here's what happens during this critical period:
Minute-by-Minute Breakdown
Platinum Zone
Highest visibility. Your reply competes with the fewest others. Hotness score: 95-100%
Gold Zone
Strong visibility, some competition. Hotness score: 85-95%
Silver Zone
Good visibility, more competition. Hotness score: 75-85%
Bronze Zone
Decent visibility, significant competition. Hotness score: 60-75%
After 60 minutes, visibility drops dramatically. By hour 6, hotness is at 45%, and by hour 24, it's down to 30%. The golden window has closed.
Understanding the Decay Curve
Twitter's engagement follows a logarithmic decay curve, not a linear decline. This means posts stay relatively "hot" longer than you might expect.
Hotness Over Time
What Hotness Scores Tell You
Fresh Posts
Best window for replies. High visibility potential.
Warm Posts
Still viable if combined with high opportunity score.
Cold Posts
Low visibility. Skip unless highly relevant.
Hotness score combines with opportunity score. A 30% hot post with 90% opportunity can still be worth replying to if you add unique value.
Timing Strategies by Goal
🎯 Maximum Visibility
Goal: Get your reply seen by the most people
- • Reply within 5-15 minutes of posting
- • Hotness target: 85%+
- • Opportunity score: 60%+
- • Works best for viral or trending posts
💬 Quality Discussion
Goal: Have meaningful conversations
- • Reply within 30-60 minutes
- • Hotness target: 70%+
- • Opportunity score: 50%+
- • Better for thought-leader content
🔗 Build Relationships
Goal: Connect with specific people
- • Reply within 1-3 hours
- • Hotness target: 60%+
- • Opportunity score: 40%+
- • Focus on connection over visibility
Common Timing Mistakes
Mistake #1: Replying Too Late
Replying to posts 12+ hours old gives you 70% less visibility than replying in the first hour. By then, the conversation has moved on.
Mistake #2: Ignoring Hotness
A high opportunity score on a cold post (20% hotness) is often not worth it. Always check both metrics.
Mistake #3: Waiting for Perfection
Spending 30 minutes crafting the perfect reply while hotness drops from 85% to 50% defeats the purpose. Ship fast, iterate.
The Actionable Framework
- 1Check hotness score first
Only engage if 70%+ for max visibility
- 2Prioritize freshness
0-15 minutes = platinum zone
- 3Combine with opportunity score
Hot + opportunity = high ROI
- 4Use feed filtering
Auto-hide posts below your threshold
- 5Reply quickly, add value
Speed + quality = success
Catch the Golden Window
Use ReplyBro to find fresh, high-opportunity posts in real-time.
Join the Waitlist